Design Your Door
Find A Dealer
Shopping for a new garage door means making choices that will shape the look and feel of your home for years to come. Real wood garage doors offer classic appeal and warmth, while faux wood garage doors—often called composite garage doors—promise a wood look with less upkeep. This guide walks you through the differences, so you can find the right fit for your style, budget, and routine.
Understanding Real Wood Garage Doors
Real wood garage doors are exactly what they sound like: doors crafted from solid wood, not just layered to look good, but built to last and feel authentic. These doors set themselves apart with their natural grain patterns, rich textures, and the one-of-a-kind warmth that only real wood can offer. If you appreciate craftsmanship and want something that feels substantial and timeless, real wood garage doors are hard to beat.
Reserve® Wood Custom garage door
Among the most popular wood types for garage doors are cedar, redwood, fir, and mahogany. Each brings its own vibe and set of benefits, making the choice more than just about looks—it’s about personality and performance.
Cedar is a classic pick for wood garage doors, and for good reason. It’s naturally resistant to rot and insects thanks to its natural oils, which means less worry when it comes to durability. Cedar has a beautiful, straight grain and a warm, reddish hue that deepens over time. It’s a favorite for homeowners who want wood grain garage doors with a rustic or craftsman feel.
Redwood stands out for its striking color and impressive stability. The grain is tight, the tones are rich, and it holds up well against warping and shrinking. Redwood is a bit of a showstopper, perfect for those who want their real wood garage doors to demand a second look from the neighbors.
Fir offers a lighter, more subtle appearance, with a straight, uniform grain that’s easy to stain or paint. It’s often used when a smooth, clean finish is the goal. Fir is a solid choice for traditional or contemporary garage door designs, especially if you want to highlight architectural details.
Mahogany is prized for its deep color and luxury finish. It’s dense, stable, and less likely to cup or twist, which makes it a great long-term investment. The grain is refined, and the overall look is sophisticated—ideal for homeowners leaning toward a high-end, elegant aesthetic.
There’s no question that real wood garage doors make a statement. While they require more upkeep than composite garage doors or faux wood garage doors, the payoff is a door that’s unique, full of character, and nearly impossible to replicate with other materials.
Benefits of Real Wood Garage Doors
The appeal of real wood garage doors starts with their natural beauty. Wood grain garage doors have a warmth and depth you just don’t get with other materials. Every panel showcases unique grain patterns—no two doors are ever the same. This natural variation, along with the rich color tones and subtle texture, gives real wood garage doors a character that stands out and can make your home feel more inviting and refined.
Customization is another major advantage. Wood is incredibly versatile, making it easy to create a garage door that matches your vision. You can choose from a wide range of woods and stains, pick out panel styles that fit your home’s architecture, and even add custom windows or decorative hardware. Clopay’s Reserve® Wood Custom garage doors, for example, let you design everything from the shape and size of the panels to the finishing touches. If you’re wondering what are the best wood looking garage doors for a truly custom project, real wood garage doors are hard to top.
Durability is often a concern, but with proper maintenance, solid wood can last for decades. Real wood garage doors are built to handle daily use and can hold up well against the elements when they’re sealed and cared for. Regular upkeep—such as refinishing or resealing—helps prevent warping and moisture damage, maintaining both appearance and structural integrity.
Considerations for Real Wood Garage Doors
While real wood garage doors offer an unmatched beauty, there are some important trade-offs to consider. First, the cost: real wood is a premium material, and that means a higher price tag compared to faux wood garage doors or composite garage doors. You’re paying for craftsmanship, customization, and quality materials, so if your budget is tight, wood vs. faux wood garage doors might tip in favor of faux wood.
Maintenance requirements are another factor. Real wood garage doors need regular attention to look and perform their best. This means routine cleaning to remove dirt and grime, as well as periodic sanding to keep the surface smooth. Staining, painting, or sealing should be done every couple of years (maybe more often if you live on the coast) to protect the wood grain garage doors from moisture, insects, and UV damage. Skipping these steps can lead to fading, warping, or even rot—especially in climates with lots of rain or extreme sun.
Also consider the climate. Places with high humidity or extreme temperature swings can cause wood to warp, crack, or rot if not properly cared for. Some species, like cedar and redwood, handle moisture better than others, but all real wood garage doors will benefit from protective coatings and consistent upkeep.
Understanding Faux Wood (Composite) Garage Doors
Faux wood garage doors, also known as composite garage doors, are built to look like real wood but use different materials and construction methods. Typically, these doors feature a steel base that provides the structure and strength. Over this, a composite overlay is added to create the appearance of wood grain garage doors. This overlay is made from materials like molded composite, fiberglass, or a blend of polyurethane and recycled wood fibers that capture the texture and patterns you’d find on actual wood.
Canyon Ridge® 5-Layer garage door
The technology behind wood-look garage doors has come a long way. At first glance, and sometimes even up close, it’s easy to mistake a faux wood garage door for the real thing. The overlays are carefully detailed to reproduce the depth and variety of natural wood. Clopay offers faux wood options, like the Canyon Ridge® Carriage House doors, with overlays that can mimic cedar, mahogany, or other popular woods, offering several stain and color choices.
Benefits of Faux Wood (Composite) Garage Doors
Faux wood garage doors are popular for a reason—they simplify life for homeowners who want the wood look without the extra work. One of the biggest advantages is lower maintenance. Thanks to the composite overlay and steel base, these doors resist rot, warping, and cracking, even in challenging climates. Unlike real wood garage doors, there’s no need for frequent sanding, staining, or sealing. The materials used are engineered to handle the elements, so you can enjoy wood grain garage doors with minimal upkeep.
Durability is another major plus. The steel base gives faux wood garage doors a strong core, making them sturdy enough to stand up to daily use and rough weather. The composite overlay adds another layer of protection, keeping the door looking new for years. This blend of materials helps shield against dents, fading, and moisture, which can be an issue for natural wood.
Cost-effectiveness is also a key part of faux wood garage door pros and cons. You get the appearance of real wood at a lower price point, which is ideal if you’re comparing wood vs faux wood garage doors on a budget. And less maintenance means fewer expenses over the life of the door.
Faux wood garage doors are also versatile and come in a wide range of styles, colors, and finishes. Whether you want something classic like the Gallery® Steel or a more modern look with Canyon Ridge® Modern, composite garage doors can be tailored to fit almost any home.
Finally, energy efficiency is built in. Many faux wood garage doors are insulated, helping keep your garage comfortable in both hot and cold seasons. The added insulation can improve your home’s overall energy performance, making these doors a smart choice.
Comparing Real Wood and Faux Wood Garage Doors: A Detailed Table
Choosing the right material depends on your priorities. If you want authentic character and don’t mind the extra upkeep, real wood is hard to beat. If you’re looking for lower maintenance, durability, and a similar wood look garage door at a better price, faux wood garage doors are a smart choice. Consider your climate, budget, and design goals to decide what are the best wood looking garage doors for your home.
Choosing the Right Material: Factors to Consider
Choosing between real wood garage doors and faux wood garage doors often comes down to a few key factors, starting with budget. If you’re working within a set budget, composite garage doors are typically more budget friendly. Real wood garage doors are a premium option, reflecting the cost of natural materials and craftsmanship. While they offer stunning, one-of-a-kind wood grain and the option for extensive customization, the price point can be a dealbreaker for some homeowners.
Maintenance preferences are just as important. For those who don’t want to spend weekends sanding, staining, or sealing, faux wood doors are appealing—they hold up well with minimal care. Composite garage doors are engineered to resist common problems like rot, warping, and cracking, making them ideal for anyone who values convenience. On the other hand, if you enjoy the process of caring for authentic wood and want a truly unique door, real wood might be worth the extra effort.
Climate should never be overlooked. Real wood can be sensitive to moisture and temperature swings, which means it may not be the best fit for areas with high humidity or harsh weather. Faux wood garage doors are better equipped to handle fluctuating conditions, requiring less attention over time.
Finally, think about your desired aesthetic. If nothing compares to the warmth and authenticity of natural wood, and you’re willing to invest in ongoing care, real wood is a standout choice. But if you want the look of wood with greater durability and less maintenance, faux wood garage doors can deliver style and curb appeal that come remarkably close to the real thing.
Clopay Garage Doors: Real Wood and Faux Wood Options
Clopay offers a variety of garage doors to suit every homeowner’s taste and budget. For those drawn to real wood garage doors, the Reserve® Wood Limited Edition stands out. These doors are handcrafted from natural wood and available in custom designs, letting you choose species, finishes, and decorative elements. The Classic™ Wood collection is another excellent choice, featuring timeless panel designs built from premium woods for traditional charm.
If you’re leaning toward faux wood garage doors, Clopay’s Canyon Ridge® Elements collection is designed to deliver the look of wood grain garage doors with the resilience of composite materials. These doors use a steel core and composite overlay for durability and realistic wood texture. The Coachman® garage doors offer the carriage house style in steel with wood-look finishes, while the Bridgeport™ Steel doors provide clean lines and classic appeal with subtle faux wood detailing.
No matter your preference, Clopay’s lineup covers both ends of the wood vs faux wood garage doors spectrum, so you can find what are the best wood looking garage doors for your style, budget, and maintenance expectations.
Take time to weigh your options and what matters most to you. For more details or to see available models, connect with a local Clopay dealer.
Helpful Articles
Garage Door Project Guide: Inspiring Makeovers
